Marrying your SO means you get an instant family, and that may include a sister-in-law!
We think it’s a good idea to get her a little (or big) something as a “thank you” for welcoming you into the family. And of course, it’s a good way to ensure you’ll always have someone in your corner when you need that extra bit of support.
But where do you even start to look for a gift that’ll tickle your sista from another mista’s taste buds? Have no fear! Our gift scouts have found 28 of the most amazing sister-in-law wedding gifts she’ll simply adore!
Soul Sister Leather Friendship Bracelet
If you’ve already built up a great friendship with your SO’s sis, then you should definitely go for this Soul Sister Leather Friendship Bracelet.
Made from leather with brass, the adjustable bracelet is available in rose gold and brown. It can also be engraved with a message of your choice, although we think “sister” sums up your relationship perfectly and will be a constant reminder of the incredible bond you share.
These bracelets combine hippie chic with Bohemian charm… so why not order one for yourself as well?
Personalized Soy Candle Gift Set
Let your future SIL know just how LIT she is with this beautifully packaged handmade Personalized Soy Candle Gift Set.
The unique candles are hand-poured and contain only the finest blends of phthalate-free essential oils.
There’s a wide range of scents available, and best of all, the candles can be personalized with your very own message on the back.
Deliver it by hand or have it posted directly to your sister-in-law’s home address.
Unicorn Sister-in-Law Mug
Almost as rare as a unicorn, an awesome sister-in-law is hard to find!
The high-quality unicorn mug can be personalized with your new sister’s name in a font of your choice. You also have the option to add a significant date.
It’s a fun gift, but packs a lot of meaning!
Hey Girl Tea Infuser Bottle with Tea Diffuser
Give your new “best-tea” a stunning gift that she’ll be able to use every day.
This Hey Girl Tea Infuser Bottle with Tea Diffuser is a must-have for any tea lover. Made from stainless steel, it’s lightweight and durable.
The diffuser works well with all sorts of loose teas, and it’s stylish to boot.
Custom Resin Coasters
Drink coasters make the perfect gift, and we especially love these custom-designed resin coasters.
Available in a wide range of colors and finishes, you also have the option to add your own text or message, as well as extra-special touches such as pressed flowers or gold or rose leaf.
Stunning and practical, your future SIL will love these.
I’d Shank A B*tch For You Candle
Nothing says “I love you” quite as much as a candle that reads “I’d Shank A B*tch For You (right in the kidney)”.
These candles are paraben, phthalate, and cruelty-free.
Each one is hand-poured in an apothecary-inspired glass jar and has a burning time of between 40 and 50 hours.
Personalized Charm and Ribbon Bookmark
If your future sista from another mista is a bibliophile (that’s an avid lover of books to you and me) then she’ll absolutely adore this gorgeous Personalized Charm and Ribbon Bookmark.
Available with rose gold, pink, orange, gray, silver, or gold ribbon, it includes a heart, moon, or star charm that can be engraved.
It’s a beautiful alternative to a traditional bookmark!
Personalized Clear Custom Case
How about this Personalized Clear Custom Phone Case as a gift for your sister-in-law?
With four different fonts to choose from, and available in a wide range of colors, you know it’s going to be used, and loved!
The One Where We Became Sisters Wine Glass
For the ‘Friends’ fan, The One Where We Became Sisters Personalized Wine Glass is a definite winner!
Add a personal touch by including the year you met or the year of your wedding.
Personalized Satin Lace Robe
We love this Personalized Satin Lace Robe and your future SIL will too.
This beautiful gift is available in white, champagne, gray, rose, and blush and can be personalized with an initial and name. It’s glamorous, comfy, and makes a great gift.
Personalized Morse Code Bracelet
This one-of-a-kind Morse code bracelet is an absolute stunner of a gift!
The bracelet itself comes in silver or gold, while the Morse code beads are available in a variety of colors, including white, cobalt, ebony, peach, and sienna, to name a few.
Toiletry Travel Bag with Hanging Hook
You can never have too many toiletry bags as far as we’re concerned, and this travel-sized one with a hanging hook is as pretty as it is practical.
Water-resistant, this cute gift includes four compartments, two-way zippers for quick access, and a metal hook to hang it up.
This sweet little heart necklace makes the perfect gift for your instant sister!
Available in rose gold, gold, or silver, the necklace comes with a message that reads:
“We may not be blood sisters, but we are still family. Thank you for everything you have always done for me. You mean more to me than you’ll ever know.”
Not much else for us to say, is there?
Premium Padfolio with Zipper
From the rich, luscious PU leather, to the smooth as butter zipper, to the smart organization that makes you look like are pro on the rise, we guarantee you’ll feel satisfied with your decision to purchase, or your money back – no gimmicks, hassle or questions asked.
Made from vegan leather, this Premium Padfolio is for the sister-in-law that likes being organized, in style.
It includes holders for pens, cards, a tablet, and a calculator. It’s water-resistant, and the zippers keep everything in place without getting crumpled.
Best of all though is the budget-friendly price!
Personalized Name Mug with Definition
This Personalized Name Mug with a Definition is a fun and quirky way to let your sister-in-law know what you love most about her.
Keep it heartfelt and sentimental or sassy and sarcastic, either way, she’ll be thinking of you every time she has a cup of tea or coffee.
Custom BFF Est. Penny Keychain
If you’re on a bit of a budget, but still want to give your SIL a thoughtful little gift, then this Custom BFF Est. Penny Keychain is an absolute winner.
Add that personal touch with a charm or birthstone. They are soooooo cute; we suggest you order one for yourself too!
Sometimes You Forget You’re Awesome Gift Set
What’s not to love about this gift set that includes a gorgeous mug with an inspirational note, as well as a mug lid, coaster, spoon, socks, and a greeting card?!
It’s everything a gal needs, all packaged in a beautiful gift box with a bow.
“My Tribe” Necklace
Finding your tribe is no small feat, so when you do, show them how much you care!
Your SIL will treasure this hand-hammered disc necklace forever. It’s got to be one of our favorite gifts on this list!
Flamingo Wearable Hooded Blanket
Your SIL will be ‘flamingly’ in style with this hooded flamingo blanket.
Hooded and gloved, this generously sized blanket is machine washable and tumble-dryer safe. This funny gift can be worn like a cloak or gown, depending on your mood. And it’s got pockets!
14K Gold Plated Cubic Zirconia Hoop Earrings
Whether it’s for her to wear on your big day, or just as a gift to show your appreciation, your sister-in-law will be besotted with these cubic zirconia hoop earrings.
Made from sterling silver, and plated with 14K yellow gold, the earrings are nickel and lead-free, which means they’re hypoallergenic.
Best Friend Forever Socks
Nothing says I love you quite as much as a pair of socks with your bonus sister’s face on! These personalized Best Friend Forever Socks are fun and easy on the budget!
You’re My Bestea Spoon
Stir things up with this You’re My Bestea Spoon. Each teaspoon is recycled, or pre-loved as we like to say, and may show signs of wear.
We love this because no spoon looks the same, giving it its own character. To finish it off, it’s hand-stamped with the message “You’re My Bestea” and includes two little hearts and a cuppa tea!
I Smile Because You are My Sister in Law Wine Tumbler
If you and your sister-in-law share the same wicked sense of humor, she’ll get a real kick out of this I Smile Because You are My Sister in Law Wine Tumbler.
BPA and lead-free, the stainless steel tumbler comes complete with a lid and is laser engraved, so the design won’t peel off, no matter how often it’s used!
Electric Coffee Warmer with Auto Shut-Off
Okay, can we just say how much we love this Electric Coffee Warmer with Auto Shut Off? The warmer allows you to keep your drink warm with the tap of a button.
It has an automatic shut-off feature that lets you know when the warmer has been on for too long. It’s also splash-resistant, so there’s no need to worry if you accidentally knock your tea or coffee over.
Bonus Sister Necklace with Charm and Birthstone
This has got to be one of the prettiest pieces of jewelry we’ve seen in a long time. Choose either the gold, silver, or rose gold necklace or adjustable bangle and personalize it with your SIL’s birthstone and initial.
Because the gemstones are 100% natural, every item is unique… just like your sister-in-law!
I Found My MISTER and Now Gained a SISTER Frame
If a picture tells a thousand words, the frame it’s in tells a thousand more.
This I Found My MISTER and Now Gained a SISTER photo clip frame is hand-made using recycled wood and is available in 15 types of finish.
What makes this frame especially beautiful is the floral images that can be printed on the background. Whether it’s her birth month flower or flowers used in the bridal bouquet, we think it adds an extra special touch.
DIY Candle Making Kit with Essential Oils
Light up her life with this DIY Candle Making Kit with Essential Oils.
The kit includes everything your SIL could possibly need to make her very own candles, including six glass jars, your own choice of scented high-grade essential oils, one dropper, a mason jar to heat the wax, soy wax, cotton wicks, chalkboard sticker labels as well as a choice of dried flowers, seashells or gemstones.
Personalized Roller Ballpoint Pen
Your future sister-in-law will be crossing her t’s and dotting her i’s in style with this personalized roller ballpoint pen.
Made from brass, the textured handle ensures a solid grip, and it’s weighted for balance.
The pen comes beautifully packaged and has a spare cartridge.
Regardless of your budget, your SIL’s taste, or style, we’re sure you’ll find the perfect gift for her from our top 29 list.
Just in case we left it out, what did you get your sista from another mista that she absolutely adored? Let us know in the comments section below.