Affordable Wedding Venues in Long Island: 10 of the Best

At Wedding Pioneer, we’re big fans of beautiful Long Island, New York, and when you’re looking for a beautiful wedding venue to fit your budget, we’ve selected the 10 Best Affordable Wedding Venues in Long Island.

But there’s more…

We also found the 12 Best Outdoor Wedding Venues in Long Island, and when you’re searching for the perfect wedding photographer, check out the 17 Best Wedding Photographers in Long Island, too!

Book More Weddings.
Join Wedding Pioneer and get your business featured on pages like this in YOUR city & state.

Key Takeaways

  • Whether you are a native New Yorker or a destination wedding couple, Long Island offers enchanting yet affordable wedding venues for both destination and local couples, presenting a variety of perfect settings from restaurants to rustic manors.
  • Budget-conscious couples can find great value on Long Island by opting for off-peak season dates, weekday events, or trimming the guest list, with venue options starting as low as $69.95 per person.
  • Venues like Harbor Links Golf Course and Beach Club Estate offer stunning backdrops, inclusive packages, and capacity for larger parties, ensuring a memorable experience without a lavish price tag.

Let’s explore your Long Island wedding venue!

Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria

Restaurant venues on Long Island, like Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria, are very affordable options.

Novita is highly recommended by local wine lovers for its elegance and impeccable service, and you can rent out the entire main dining room or select a private space.

Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria offers a great menu and wine selection, with various catering and bar packages available. Of course, their specialty is Italian cuisine and a hundred different wines from around the world.

  • Price Range: $79 per person for a four-hour rental and $89 per person for a five-hour rental (100 guests minimum).
  • Capacity: Up to 200 guests.

Find Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria at Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria or check out Facebook or Instagram.

Ariana Waterfall

With an all-inclusive package including catering, beer, wine, and a wedding cake, the Ariana Waterfall wedding space is affordable and glamorous.

Additional wedding amenities include a DJ, limousine, and floral arrangements, and the palatial ballroom features marble floors and chandeliers, with a capacity of 200 guests.

Discuss your dream wedding with Ariana Waterfall’s onside wedding planners!

  • Price Range: Around $10,000.
  • Capacity: Up to 200 guests.

Find Ariana Waterfall at The Knot or check out Facebook.

Harbor Links Golf Course

You can hold your wedding outdoors in season at Harbor Links, or choose this beautiful, impeccably groomed golf course as your indoor wedding venue off-season.

If you get married on a weekend in the off-season, the cost is $55 per person compared to $130 during peak times in spring or summer!

The outdoor reception area is romantic with a covered gazebo and beautiful views, and indoors you will find the Grand Ballroom.

  • Price Range: $55-$130 per guest.
  • Capacity: Up to 250 guests.

Find Harbor Links Golf Course at Harbor Links Golf Course or check out Facebook.

Sunset Harbor

Sunset Harbor has a gorgeous waterside setting on Long Island Sound that’s ideal for an intimate wedding ceremony on the outdoor deck.

The main wedding space indoors is the banquet hall and a remarkable ballroom for up to 250 guests.

  • Price Range: $10,000 for up to 100 guests.
  • Capacity: Up to 250.

Find Sunset Harbor at Sunset Harbor or check out Facebook, Pinterest, or Instagram.

The Garden at Farmingdale

This fun and relaxing wedding venue is located on the top floor of Croxley’s, an alehouse in Farmdale. Wedding couples love the retractable roof on this alehouse, giving it an indoor-outdoor feel!

With a capacity for up to 150 guests, you can book a four-hour rental including a buffet, dinner, cocktails, a wedding cake, and dessert.

  • Price Range: $69.95 per person.
  • Capacity: Up to 150 guests.

Find The Garden at Farmingdale at The Garden at Farmingdale or check out Facebook or Instagram.

Captain Bill’s Bayview House

Captain Bill’s is another affordable waterfront restaurant with a relaxing feel and amazing views of the harbor on the back deck.

If you still want a touch of glamor, The Bayview Room offers stunning cathedral windows and crystal chandeliers, while The Waterview Room is ideal for your bridal shower or rehearsal dinner.

  • Price Range: $82 per guest.
  • Capacity: Up to 250 guests.

Find Captain Bill’s Bayview House at Captain Bill’s Bayview House or check out Facebook, TikTok, or Instagram.

Beach Club Estate

You’ll enjoy the tropical feel at the Beach Club Estate, located on Lake Ronkonkoma, where you can hold an outside ceremony or an indoor setting in the lakeside chapel.

The all-inclusive wedding packages include the venue, limousine service, open bar, a DJ, wedding cake, and much more.

The gorgeous property is filled with gardens and waterfalls and is perfect for photo opportunities.

  • Price Range: $9,995 for 100 guests.
  • Capacity: Up to 150 guests.

Find Beach Club Estate at Beach Club Estate or check out Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, or Instagram.

Chateau La Mer

Travel to the South Bay in Long Island, and you’ll find a European-inspired waterfront venue called Chateau La Mer.

You can choose from indoor or outdoor spaces for your wedding, and you’ll enjoy the waterfalls and lush gardens for great wedding photos and videos!

The outside veranda has bay views, and the gorgeous ballrooms indoors have marble and granite floors, luxurious draperies, and crystal chandeliers.

  • Price Range: Packages start at $12,000.
  • Capacity: Up to 300 guests.

Find Chateau La Mer at Chateau La Mer or check out Facebook or Instagram.

The Mansion at West Sayville

This historic waterfront venue was built in 1909, and the Mansion at West Sayville has excellent views of the South Bay.

The waterfront docks are ideal for romantic wedding photos, and this outdoor area is also ideal for your seasonal wedding ceremony.

There is a range of all-inclusive wedding packages available at the Mansion, and this rustic-chic spot holds plenty of charm for the wedding couple and their guests.

  • Price Range: Packages start at $11,995.
  • Capacity: Up to 200 guests.

Find The Mansion at West Sayville at Mansion at The Mansion at West Sayville or check out Facebook, Youtube, or Instagram.

Peconic River Herb Farm

The Peconic River Herb Farm is a botanical paradise on a fourteen-acre working nursery.

They boast 8 greenhouses and a riverfront lawn, ideal for a romantic ceremony site, and your wedding rental package includes a full weekend of strolling the grounds and enjoying stunning riverfront views.

  • Price Range: Contact the farm for seasonal pricing.
  • Capacity: From at least 10 guests up to 150 guests.

Find Peconic River Herb Farm at Peconic River Herb Farm or check out Facebook, Pinterest, or Instagram.

More From Blog

Where to Honeymoon in January: 15 Beautiful Destinations

14 Best Eagles Wedding Songs for a Timeless Celebration

Where to Honeymoon in Greece: 6 Amazing & Romantic Options

Thank you!

This feature will be available shortly, we’ll notify you when it’s ready. For now, please take a look at our hand-selected vendors.

Enter to win a free All-inclusive honeymoon

4 days/3 nights at any Sandals resort (airfare not included)