Bridesmaid Proposal Box Fillers for Every Budget

Small gifts and personal touches to fill a proposal box, from candles and scrunchies to jewelry she'll keep.

Free Wedding Package

Sandals Will Throw Your Wedding for Free

Stay 7 nights in a Club or Butler suite and Sandals covers the wedding: a personal planner, the ceremony, a private cocktail reception, a two-tier cake, your bouquet and boutonniere, plus $200 toward photos and $200 toward video. No venue hunt, no vendor juggling.

See the Free Package

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Every piece below is sold by an independent maker on Etsy — 15 picks in all. Under each one is the seller’s own description, so you can check the material, sizing and details before you click through.

1. Bubble Letter Stud Earrings

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Save Article

Save this for later. I'll send it right to your inbox so it's there when you need it—plus a little extra wedding magic along the way.

Email

SAVE THIS ARTICLE

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Our dainty Initial Charm Earrings are personalized to any letter, making them not only a wonderful bridal party gift, but a gift for anytime you want to show someone you care.

2. Burgundy Bead Necklace

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Deep red burgundy graduated necklace The color of this necklace is just gorgeous.It is rich dark red- burgundy. The necklace is made with 3 size smooth glass beads.It is finished with high quality silver findings and stainless steel extender chain to adjust the length. The necklace measures 18 inches plus two inches with the extender chain.

3. Teardrop Zircon Crystal Earrings

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

I made them using: – 18x13mm Crystal pear shaped stones – Cubic Zirconia component – 18 inches chain with a 2 inches extender – All of the above parts are luster rhodium plated.

4. Bridesmaid Gift Stickers

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Our Wedding Party Proposal ICED Labels are the perfect addition to your proposal party or bridal shower.

5. Personalized Diamond Pen

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Taxes included for Canadian customers even if Taxes = 0$ in your receipt (Etsy bug This personalized diamond pen will be a perfect gift for your bridesmaids proposal box, for your guest book, to thank a teacher or please a girl who loves stationery. 6 color choices are offered to you, 3 with gold color finishes and 3 others with rose gold color finishes.

6. Initials Coin Wallet

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Surprise your bridesmaids with this elegant Small Handbag Purse & Credit Card Holder, a thoughtful and practical gift they'll use daily.

7. Velvet Bridesmaid Proposal Scrunchie

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Perfect for the bride-to-be who wants a minimalist yet thoughtful way to ask her best friends to stand by her side.

8. Brown Bridesmaid Proposal Gift

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

A sweet addition to your bridesmaid proposal boxes, these ombré creaseless hair ties come on a customized card that says "I can't tie the knot without you!". This set includes three hair ties per card. Custom orders are always welcome.

9. Personalised Pocket Mirror

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Share your appreciation of all they do for you by telling us what name you would like us to personalise on the front of the mirror in a lovely script font.

10. Customized Frosted Glass Tumbler

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

NEW ITEM SALE These exquisite and elegant, frosted glass tumblers are perfect for Bridesmaid Proposals, Iced Coffee Lovers, Girls trips, Friends/Birthday/Christmas gifts or just for any special occasion. These customized glass tumblers are very unique with frosted glass and lovely bamboo lids.

11. Lavender Geode Skinny Tumbler

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Lavender Geode Tumblers can be customized with your Your name and Text. Our Personalized Tumblers can come in our Delux Gift Box Packaging. Custom names and design are printed directly on the tumbler.

12. Bridesmaid Tote Bag

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

These totes are the perfect gift for your wedding party.

13. Personalized Pashmina Shawl Scarf

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

These pashminas are HIGH QUALITY items (not 120 grams sold at a lower price).

14. Light Gray Pashmina Shawl

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

These items are real items produced in the one of the textile center in TURKEY.

15. Bridesmaid Proposal Calendar Card

Handmade seller

See it on Etsy

Affiliate link to Etsy. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

This beautiful Save the Date Calendar cards are a perfect addition to your bridesmaid proposal boxes.